Cookie Jar

Nestled in the heart of Staten Island at 1226 Forest Ave, Cookie Jar is much more than a typical cookie shop — it’s a haven for cookie enthusiasts, coffee lovers, and dessert aficionados alike. Combining the warmth of a bakery with the inviting charm of a cozy coffee shop, Cookie Jar artfully blends tradition and creativity, offering a delightful experience that keeps customers coming back time and again.

Step inside, and you'll immediately notice the enchanting display of cookie jars lining one entire wall, each brimming with an assortment of uniquely crafted confections. This whimsical setup perfectly encapsulates the shop’s spirit—wholesome nostalgia meets inventive flavors. Whether you’re after a comforting classic or eager to try something new, Cookie Jar presents an irresistible selection that caters to all taste buds.

The menu highlights are a journey in themselves. Their Chocolate Chip Cookie boasts that perfect balance between chewy and crisp, with rich chocolate morsels that melt just so. For those craving a touch of decadence, the Red Velvet Cake Shake is a revelation — velvety, lush, and satisfyingly smooth, it’s a dessert drink that feels both indulgent and comforting. The Chocolate Linzer offers a sophisticated nutty richness, while their lattes and expertly brewed teas provide the perfect counterpoint to their baked goods, inviting you to linger a little longer.

Visitors consistently praise Cookie Jar’s unique quality—a sentiment beautifully captured by loyal customer D L, who shares a remarkable story of traveling 191 miles just to savor these unmatched cookies. They attribute this singular flavor to the distinctive New York water and the artisanal skill of the bakers, making each bite an authentic taste of Staten Island’s charm.

First-timers like Sreelekshmy Panicker often find themselves overwhelmed—in the best possible way—by the extensive variety. After sampling their diverse cookie collections, many feel compelled to take home a piece of Cookie Jar magic, often in the form of an iconic cookie jar that makes a thoughtful and delightful gift. Regulars like Vacation Joe appreciate not only the delectable baked goods but also the inviting ambiance, complete with seating that encourages savoring your treat on-site while enjoying freshly brewed coffee or refreshing frozen cappuccinos.

Cookie Jar’s commitment to quality and creativity shines through in every offering. Whether you’re indulging in the soft and moist Red Velvet Whoopie, lauded by Sophia Chizuco as “the BEST cookie so far,” or exploring seasonal flavors like strawberry and lemon as P Z did, the experience is consistently memorable. This is a place where each cookie tells a story, crafted with care and backed by years of loyal customers’ glowing praise.

In a world where many treats can feel mass-produced or fleeting, Cookie Jar stands out as an enduring treasure—an invitation to slow down, savor, and celebrate the art of the cookie. For seasoned Staten Island locals and curious visitors alike, it’s not just a stop on the map, but a sweet destination that remains etched in memory long after the last crumb is enjoyed.

Cookie Jar is reachable at +1 718-448-3500, ready to welcome you into a world of irresistible flavors and genuine warmth.